“We have, in fact, two kinds of morality side by side; one which we preach but do not practice, and another which we practice but seldom preach” – Bertrand Russell
Ah morality my old friend. The choice between right and wrong, to decide whether to side with temptation or truth. It is often obvious which path in life we should lead. The morality of a choice is often poke you in the bellybutton obvious. However that is not always the path that we do take. Indeed I enjoy taking a wander down the odd immoral path every now and then. It makes life that bit more spicy. Saying that though I am generally a moral person, I like to make the people around me happy and occasionally feel that warm glow of a good deed done. And naturally I would like to be a moral best man. But what is it to be a ‘moral’ best man? Judging by Hollywood folklore it means getting JR to the church on time. I will only need to dampen a few last minute nerves and that can be done with a simple ‘memories montage’, a bit of Simply Red in the background and an essential hearty slap on the back.
But is that really the case? Is ensuring that the status quo is maintained the correct moral decision? I am not going to debate the ins and outs of morality, i took a philosophy degree for that, however I am going to question whether simply ensuring that the wedding takes place is always the right decision. Take the following three real life stories. What should the moral best man do?
1) It is the day before the wedding and the BM (best man) and GR (groom) are sitting down having a pint in pub. They are running through the final preparations for the next day, groomsmen are being paired up with rogue grannies and it has been realised that the buttonholes should have been picked up earlier. A handy brother has been dispatched to collect them as the pub dwellers dispatch a few more pints of their own. Once all the business has been concluded talk naturally turns to the future. Then the GR drops a bombshell of epic proportions. He says that he has been having second thoughts about the wedding. The BM, as any good BM will be, is prepared for this and launches into the ‘it is natural to have pre wedding nerves’ spiel. However he sees the GR shaking his head before admitting that he has been heavily flirting with another woman, who is part of the wedding party, for the last two months. Nothing has happened but they have both said that if the situation was different that they would like to try and get together. What does the BM do? Options i) Help arrange an escape for the GR ii) Try to talk the GR into still getting married iii) Tell the bride iv) Get them to the altar!
2) The BM is in the lucky position of knowing both the GR and the blushing bride extremely well as they grew up together. Aged six he remembers them both playing ‘show me yours and I’ll show you mine’ only for the bride to get cold feet and leaving the GR with his wedding tackle out in the middle of the playground. The BM organises a brilliant stag night, a heavy day of paintballing goes well and they head off for V.I.P. entry into a nightclub. After hitting the shot bar they decide to show off their excellent dance moves on the floor. A blonde soon starts dancing with the GR but BM thinks little of it, it is his last night freedom, let him have a little fun. After all what happens on the stag do stays on the stag do right? When he returns from one of his many trips to the toilet he finds that the GR has disappeared as has the blonde. He tries to get in touch with the GR but to no avail. The next morning the GR turns up sheepishly at the hotel with three hickies and a tall tale. He eventually admits to the BM what has happened; one night of passionate debauchery which he swears will never happen again. What does the BM do? Options i) what happens on the stag do stays on the do, tell no-one ii) Talk the GR into telling the bride by asking him if he could look his childhood sweetheart in the eye iii) Tell the bride, after all she is also one of his best friends iv) Get them to the altar!
3) The BM says it is surprising seeing how loved up the GR is. Flowers and chocolates are showered on the bride; they are permanently attached at the hip and do nothing without asking the other. They got engaged after three months. The BM is happy for his mate however he admits to his friends that it feels like he has lost his best friend. The day before the wedding the BM takes the GR out for a curry and talk turns to the big day. Much as in the first story it has been realised that buttonholes have been forgotten, I’m noticing a trend here, and also that the GR has managed to lose his speech. After quickly penning a new version the BM turns the conversation to the bride. The GR grins and begins gushing about how much he loves her, the BM couldn’t quite remember exactly what was said but said that he remembered a plethora of flower analogies. The BM then asked the million dollar question; “but will you for the rest of your life”? Here the GR faltered. He began questioning a lot of things; I love her now, but will I for ever? Did I rush into this after all we’ve only known each other three months? What if I meet someone else? Is she really the one? What if I’m making a huge mistake? Much as in Friends he has a Chandler Bing style freak out. What should the BM do? Options i) Give the GR a slap and tell him to stop being silly ii) Tell the GR to have a chat with the bride about this, see if she is feeling the same and maybe postpone the wedding iii) Help the GR to escape, possible involving a hot air balloon and speedboat iv) Get them to the altar!
Now it is not my place to judge but personally I do not think that the solution to all of the above situations is the same. The whole idea of ‘get them to the church’ does not always seem to hold true. Should the best man keep his mouth shut if he finds out that the GR is a cheat? Is the best mans only moral responsibility whether or not the wedding day passes off successfully? Or does it encompass more than that? In this humble best mans opinion my personal moral conscience would not simply cover the wedding day itself. If I did not think that a couple was right for each other, and about to commit to marriage, then I think that I would be morally obliged to say something. This is especially true if I knew one of the pair to be unfaithful.
But that is just me. Every person is different and not every situation is the same. If a groom has picked you to be their best man that means that they understand and trust your moral compass, alongside the other essential qualities of a best friend. If you morally think that something should be done, and that importantly the groom would objectively believe the same, then it is probably the right decision.
This is what happened in the above cases;
1) The best man took the second option and stuck to his guns. He tried to talk the groom into going through with the wedding because the other woman was simply a passing phase. However the groom rejected his advice and called off the wedding. He got together with the ‘other women’ and split up after two months.
2) The best man took the first option and did nothing. The wedding went perfectly and they had two children. Three weeks after the second child was born it came out that he had had a string of affairs. They split up and the best man is now in a relationship with the bride.
3) The best man took the second option. The bride was also feeling the same however they decided to go ahead with the wedding anyway. They have been happily married for the last six years and have three children.
Did any the best men make the right decision? What would you have done?
Next week; important things a best man should carry on the day.
DO NOT FORGET THE RING!